This is from our weekly Discourse newsletter. Make sure to share it and subscribe here.
When Justin Trudeau commented on how women are at a higher risk for sexualized violence near temporary work camps at the G20 in Argentina last week, Conservative Twitter blew up.
Alberta’s Conservative Party leader, Jason Kenney called Trudeau’s comments “hurtful” and dismissed his concerns.
And federal Conservative leader Andrew Scheer said, “The person who is a threat to rural Canada is Justin Trudeau himself, not the workers who build communities everywhere.” He accused Trudeau of demonizing construction workers.
Truth is that both perspectives have some merit. The camps, and their workers, do contribute economically. But there is also a real connection to sexualized violence against women, as The Discourse reporters Emma Jones and Francesca Fionda found in their award-winning investigation Shadow Population, which dug into the human impacts of the camps.
The Twitter skirmish shows how Scheer’s gang is increasingly engaging in political dialogue purposely designed to polarize Canadians on wedge issues. But by pitting men in the resource industry against women, he is silencing victims.
Women’s perspectives are essential. Globally, women are only mentioned in 25 per cent of news stories, and usually in supporting roles. We need stories that highlight that.
But the reality is that we’ll never understand violence against women if we don’t listen to men’s stories too. Our Shadow Population coverage also revealed how workers deal with a unique set of physical and mental health challenges — and how services to support them vary significantly.
We need to engage in nuanced conversations that include all Canadians if we want to to create a country in which both women and men thrive.