Local filmmaker brings Canada’s betrayal of Haiti to light

Nanaimo-based filmmaker Elaine Brière discusses her film Haiti Betrayed: How Canada Destroyed a Democracy and why film gives voice to human rights.
A black and white photo of a Haitian woman walks past a UN truck parked on the sidewalk and half blocking the street.
A Haitian woman walks past a UN tank parked on the sidewalk and half blocking the street in early 2011. Photo courtesy of Elaine Brière

How does a former Ladysmith resident become an international photojournalist and documentary filmmaker? Elaine Brière, director and producer of Haiti Betrayed: How Canada Destroyed a Democracy has an idea.

“I started off as a human rights advocate. I wanted to help tell stories that were being hidden and the camera was the best way I could go about that,” she says. Brière’s photojournalism and photo activism have appeared in the Globe & Mail, the New York Review, Canadian Geographic, Amnesty International and Switzerland’s Neue Zurcher Zeitung

Her use of black and white photography and silver film videography has been a key tool in showcasing human rights movements. Photography in her book, East Timor: Testimony, showcases the struggles and triumphs of East Timor as the people survived colonization and invasion.

Her film Bitter Paradise: The Sell-out of East Timor won Best Political Documentary at the 1997 HOT DOCS! film festival.

Your Nanaimo newsletter

When you subscribe, you’ll get Nanaimo This Week straight to your inbox every Thursday — giving you the first peek at our latest investigations, local news updates, upcoming events and ways to get involved in our community.

It was a camera around her neck that sparked Brière’s intertwining history with Haiti. In 2009, while in Port-au-Prince with her partner, who was working on water infrastructure in the region, Brière was approached by a Haitian in the town square of Cham Mas.

“He was shouting, ‘Blan, blan, (foreigner) you don’t know what is happening here,'” Brière recounts. “He wasn’t being aggressive, he was just very tired of the truth not being told, of people not understanding why Haiti is in the position it’s in.”

Brière would later learn the man was from Cité Soleil, a heavily impoverished commune near Port-au-Prince that’s been under United Nations Stabilization Mission watch since 2004.

“Taking off his hat, he spoke again,” she recounts. “‘They are killing us!  We are poor people. Life is very hard. Tell them what they are doing to us. Tell them to stop.’ He began to cry. I held his hand until he composed himself. Then he put on his hat and slowly walked away. And this film is my response to that request.”

A black and white photo of Haitians marching in the street twoards the camera. Signs are held by some calling for democratic liberty
In 2011, Hatians take to the streets to call for the return of independent elections and democracy. Photo courtesy of Elaine Brière

Thus began Brière’s deep dive into all that Haiti has been up against since its 1791 revolution. Though considered one the most successful revolutions in human history, France refused to recognize Haitian independence. As one quote in the film explains, “Haiti could not succeed. You could not have a former slave colony become a democratic republic. That has been the goal to destroy Haiti since.”

A key player in the recent acts to destabilize Haiti’s democracy? Canada, which once served as a refuge for thousands of Haitians fleeing violence between 1957 and 1990. But in the decade that followed, Canada participated in various interventions that continued to throw Haiti’s democracy into crisis.

“Haitians used to love Canada. Many of them still do. But they feel so very betrayed by our government and how Canada helped topple their democratic government in 2003.”

A black and white photo of a Haitian woman wearing a weaved sunhat that casts a checkered shadow over her face. She looks pensively at the camera, head tilted to the side. In her right hand is a campaign pamphlet for the 2001 Haiti elections
A supporter of former president Jean-Bertrand Aristide holds up a campaign pamphlet in 2011. Photo courtesy of Elaine Brière

In her film, first released in 2019, Brière meticulously reconstructs Canada’s role in the events that led to the United Nations-sanctioned coup d’état on Feb. 29, 2004 and the crushing aftermath that followed.

“We claim ourselves this peace-keeping power in the world. We pride ourselves on being the good guys. But this little nation, who really galvanized the human rights movement by overthrowing slavery, has suffered so much because of the Canadian government’s actions. And citizens need to know that. Haiti deserves so much from the world because of all that beautiful little island has given us.”

Haiti Betrayed: How Canada Destroyed a Democracy can be rented online. A screening will be hosted at the Vancouver Island Regional Library on Saturday, Feb. 11.

Double your impact today!

Your contribution to The Discourse's independent journalism will be matched, up to $10,000.

bailey macabre holding the tote they designed for The Discourse in 2022. The tote shows the word

This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy.

Scroll to Top